Hi, I’m Lauren

Element of Fashion was created to be your hub of style inspiration, whether you need insight on dinner parties, travel musings, or just outfit ideas.

Boy Girl Twin Party Themes for First Birthday

Boy Girl Twin Party Themes for First Birthday

Element of Fashion uses affiliate links. By clicking on certain hyperlinks and buying a product, you may help me make a small commission off your purchase. It's links like these that keep this site going. Thank you for your support!

I told myself I’d have my boy girl twin first birthday theme posts up before their half birthday; however, they turned 1.5 earlier this month and this went unwritten. To be fair to myself, my twins actually had 2 different birthday parties - one here in LA that was lemon themed. ( At least I posted that one well before they were1.5!) We also had one in Dallas and that party is what this post is about. The date and time were the same for each twin; however, I had 2 different themes. Yes, I had a total of 2 parties for them and 3 different themes. Hah! For a quick peak, you can see this video I made from the day here.

Keep reading to see details of the party and garner inspiration for an upcoming party!

A friend asked me the other day the reasoning I had behind two separate themes and if I had read it somewhere. It honestly just comes from experience. I have one sister and our birthdays are literally back to back, though three years apart - August 2nd and August 3rd. We always had the best birthday parties, our own themes, and on different days. It helped make us feel special even though they were so close to each other. Not that they will remember, but I didn’t think it was fair to box the twins into the same theme, as they are two different people with their own likes, dislikes, and personalities.

I love a good party theme, so I actually keep a running note on my iPhone with ideas for them! For Olive, our little girl, the theme was The Good Ship Ollipop, like Shirley Temple’s The Good Ship Lollipop. It is a cute play on O’s name and sassy-sweet just like her. I also love that Shirley Temple puts her pointer finger up, which was very fitting for a first birthday. The main color in Shirley’s dress is red, so I went with a pinky red for Olive’s pop color. For Cyprus, our little boy, his theme was Number One Cype Man, like Number One Hype Man, but again another play on his name / we often call him Cype. He gets so excited and happy and pumps you up, so I thought it was the perfect theme for him. I was kind of thinking Jump Man / Nike / Sportish if the theme doesn’t make sense to you. This concept was a bit harder to create, but I love how it turned out. Since I was thinking sporty, the pop color I used for this was green, kind of like a turf green. To bring both themes together, I used black. It wasn’t my first choice as the neutral, but it was fall and I think black worked really well.

If you’re stuck on a theme and can’t figure out any workable ideas, I would start with what they like. Do they have a favorite food or book? Are there any plays on their name you can do? Once you consider these things, you’ll likely have at least one good idea!!


Canva is my best friend! Once I chose the themes, I went to work on their invitations. Like I mentioned on their other first birthday party, I really wanted mail invitations; however, I didn’t have time. I created these cute images and texted them out to friends and family. I will print copies out for their baby books… which clearly I have not done yet either. Hah!

Olive’s invitation was fairly easy, as I took the actual Good Ship Lollipop font, as well as the pattern from Shirley Temple’s dress to make the background. I already had the photo of her with her finger, so I removed the background (on remove.bg) and found a life preserver image I liked and went from there.

Cyprus’ was simple once I figured out what to do. I was at a loss, but then I decided a grassy background would be perfect! I found a foam finger photo I liked, removed the background on the image I chose, and went from there.

It’s always a fun idea to have the invitation on display at a party, to really bring the theme to life!


My favorite section!! I wanted Olive to look like Shirley Temple, so I found her dress at Gap. It’s sold out now, but if you want to search for it, the name of it was Baby Flannel Tiered Dress. Also… I have two because I thought I lost one? So let me know if you want the extra! I bought this collar (yes it is adult size, but it worked!) on Amazon to make it more Shirley Temple-esque and then added a black ribbon for the final touch. Oh and of course a big black bow! Her headband was a gift, so I’m not sure where it was from, but she also has these clips and they are perfect. I loved this look because it easily re-wearable. She actually wore it around Christmas and Valentine’s Day, sans collar!

For Cyprus I kept with the red / black / green color scheme and he wore black jeans he already had, but I made him a special shirt. I had seen similar designs elsewhere, but I didn’t want to shell out the cash to cover it and I knew I could make it myself. It has a cute little number 1 hand and his name, which I love! He gets a lot of wear out of it as well. I think I will make him a “2” one too! I didn’t want Olive to be left out, so I actually med her one as well. If you want to buy one instead, they have these at Maisonette and these on Etsy.

For Nick, I actually made him a “Papa” version of Cyprus’ shirt and then I just wore an old, black, Topshop dress I had with shorts underneath it so I could move around easier and it was perfect. I’m big on re-wearing things for as long as I can, so I felt really good about these party outfits.


Lollipops (We lined the grass with these and also hand them randomly around the house / in vases.)

Balloon Arch (I wasn’t sure what color to do, but I like how the black and silver set turned out!)

Turf (We put this under the chocolate cupcake tiered tray, basically as decor, no real use, but it tied everything together.)

Foam Finger (We used this as a photo op prop for Cyprus.)

Life Preserve (We used this as a photo op prop for Olive. I bought the preserve as is and my mom put sticker letters on it to say “Good Ship Ollipop.”

Tableware. (We had black and white buffalo plaid plates and then plain black cups, and black napkins. I was worried it would be too dark, but it was our perfect pop color.)

Burlap Swag - I brought this with me because we used it at the LA party and stenciled “one” on them, but I forgot to hang them up.


Circus Animal Cookies

Animal Crackers

Sally’s Baking Addiction Strawberry Cupcakes

Sally’s Baking Addiction Chocolate Cupcakes

Sally’s Baking Addiction Sugar Cookies (listed in the “party activites” section)



Cheese Quesadillas (cut into strips - these went so fast!)

Vegetable Tray (This was kind of intense, but I had Nick make a ship to put in front of the veggie tray. You can see from the photos, but there were little cucumber boats with a bell pepper/toothpick pole and a cucumber slice sail. There’s a little mozzarella flag and then ranch in the boat, topped with a red lifesaver gummy. These were next to the veggie tray, along with homemade ranch dip.)


I love chocolate cake, but we don’t plan on introducing chocolate until the twins are 2+ years old so both of the cakes were more of a vanilla flavor. I shared the refined-sugar free and dye-free cake recipe I used for the twins here and it was delicious! I’m very happy with how they turned out. Would 100% do again! You can check out all the details on the cake specific post, but they each had their own cake and had different color (natural) frostings. Cyprus’ was green and Olive’s was pink. They were three layered / 6” cakes, so dramatic like a smash cake usually is, but also kid friendly and on the smaller side. I

Side note, I took off their clothes while they ate cake and just put these mushie bibs on them to make clean up easier.


I like favors that people will actually enjoy / are fun! I went with an easy snack grab bucket by the front door, filled with themed Cyprus and Olive treats. Because it was mostly adults, with a handful of children, there wasn’t really a point to have baby / kid friendly items.

I bought boxes of Cracker Jacks for Cyprus’ favor and Organic + Dye Free Lollipops as Olive’s favor. I grabbed printable round stickers to print their faces on to make them personalized. I chose the photos, then removed the background by uploading them to remove.bg (free website), then created the sticker file on Canva (free version) and printed via Word. I loved how they turned out!!


This was the exact same as the other first birthday party I threw them. While the twins obviously couldn’t write their own notes yet, I did want them to participate. I bought blank mailable sized folded cards and some non-toxic crayons. They literally tried to eat them, so that’s why I went with a “cleaner” brand. They are also chunky and easier for a little hand to hold! I wrote THANK YOU on the card, then let the twins color on them. I of course wrote the note on the inside; regardless, people eat this up and it feels really special. And they should! In today’s day and age, people are incredible flaky, so I personally was very thankful for those who made my twins a priority.


While we didn’t have any kids at our LA party, we did have some children at our Dallas party! There weren’t a ton, so I didn’t feel the need to do a soft play feature or ball pit; however, I wanted something for kids as well as adults to do. Social anxiety can be crippling, so I wanted an activity for people to do where they could use their hands and relax. I decided a cookie decorating station was the best bet! I used Sally’s Baking Addiction sugar cookie recipe and purchased themed cookie cutters. I bought a lollipop shape for Olive and a foam finger shape for Cyprus. I thought I had alphabet cookie cutters, but couldn’t find them. It was my plan to do one set of each of their names in addition to the fun shapes; however, I didn’t realize they were missing until it was too late to order a set. I used leftover frosting from their birthday cakes and the cupcakes I made for people to frost themselves and provided toppings like dye free sprinkles and candies like Unreal Chocolate Gems to decorate with.

I hope this inspired you for your party!! Birthday parties can be stressful, but personally I have such good memories of mine. You’re doing a great job and even if your child doesn’t remember it, you will. Make the memories! Just don’t stress too much ;) XOXO

Like what you read? Click here to subscribe to my weekly newsletter. I recap the week and share recent posts you might have missed!

May Favorites

May Favorites

April Favorites

April Favorites